Best Books to Read When Choosing a College

Share post
Posted On: October 1, 2025
Jump to

Key Points

  • These three book recommendations three books are meant to help students and families build a college list focused on fit, values, and opportunity, not just prestige.
  • “The Hidden Ivies” highlights many lesser-known colleges that match elite academic quality and offer smaller class sizes and strong student experiences.
  • “Colleges That Change Lives” emphasizes colleges that prioritize student growth, teaching quality, and personal development over rankings or status.
  • “Fiske Guide to Colleges” provides balanced, honest descriptions of 300+ colleges — mixing data with narrative — to help families think more broadly about which schools fit their goals.

If June is for writing, then July is for researching—and rethinking. Whether your student has already drafted a dream list or has no clue where to start, this month’s picks are designed to broaden perspectives and challenge assumptions. Because a strong college list isn’t just about prestige—it’s about purpose, fit, and future possibilities. These three books will help you and your student think critically and expansively about what matters most as they choose a college.


1. The Hidden Ivies – Howard Greene & Matthew Greene

Why we love it:
This guide highlights more than 60 “lesser-known” colleges and universities that rival the Ivies in academic rigor, student experience, and outcomes.[1] It’s a great reminder that excellence comes in many forms—and often in smaller class sizes.

“College is not just a stepping stone to a career—it’s a transformational journey.”

Perfect for parents who are hoping to expand their student’s college list beyond the usual suspects.

Did you know?
The authors are a father-son counseling team with decades of experience, and the original edition helped launch the now widely used phrase Hidden Ivies.


2. Colleges That Change Lives – Loren Pope

Why we love it:
First published in the 1990s and updated since, this classic profiles 40 colleges that focus deeply on student growth, teaching quality, and lifelong learning.[2] Pope champions schools where students are seen, not scanned—and where potential is nurtured with care.

“No matter how you define success, you are more likely to find it at a college that fits.”

Perfect for parents who want to refocus the conversation on personal development, not just admissions outcomes.

Did you know?
The book inspired a national movement and nonprofit of the same name—Colleges That Change Lives (CTCL)—which still hosts information fairs and supports under-the-radar gems across the country.[3]


3. Fiske Guide to Colleges – Edward B. Fiske

Why we love it:
Now in its 40th edition, this trusted resource offers thoughtful, candid write-ups of over 300 colleges and universities.[4] Fiske balances data with narrative, offering insights that go far beyond stats and rankings. It’s our go-to reference for well-rounded research.

“It’s not just about getting in—it’s about fitting in.”

Perfect for parents who want a comprehensive, balanced tool to use during list-building conversations (and campus visits).

Did you know?
Edward Fiske, the education editor of The New York Times, created this guide to offer a more personal, journalistic lens into higher education options.


Final Note

A well-built college list is one of the most important (and overlooked) parts of the application process. These books will help you and your student move beyond name recognition toward purpose-driven choices.

Looking for a deeper dive on school list strategy? Check out our guide: How to Build a Balanced College List.

And if you’re feeling overwhelmed by the sheer number of options, don’t worry—we’ve read them all. Reach out to your InGenius counselor for a free consultation, and we can help you create a customized school list that reflects your student’s story and goals.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I start choosing a college that’s right for me?

Begin by identifying your priorities—academic programs, campus culture, size, location, cost, and opportunities like internships or study abroad. Once you know what matters most, you can build a college list that fits your goals.

What are the most important factors to consider when picking colleges?

Students often focus on rankings, but factors like major availability, student support services, financial aid, and career outcomes are equally important. Your ideal college pick should match both your interests and your long-term plans.

What are some good books about college admissions to help with the process?

Popular choices include guides on crafting applications, understanding selective admissions, and navigating the college search strategically. These books can help you make informed decisions as you build your college list and prepare to apply.

How many schools should be on my college list?

Most experts recommend applying to 8–12 colleges across a balanced mix of reach, match, and likely schools. This approach gives you strong options without overwhelming your application workload.

What’s the best way to compare colleges before deciding where to go to school?

Create a comparison chart including factors like academic strengths, campus life, affordability, and student outcomes. Visiting campuses—virtually or in person—also helps you gauge whether a school feels like the right fit.

School Admissions Guides

Sources

[1] Greene, H., & Greene, M. W. (2016). The Hidden Ivies, 3rd Edition: 63 of America’s Top Liberal Arts Colleges and Universities. HarperCollins.

[2] Pope, L. (2012). Colleges that change lives: 40 schools that will change the way you think about colleges (4th ed.). Penguin Books.

[3] Colleges That Change Lives. (n.d.). CTCL: Colleges That Change Lives. https://ctcl.org/

[4] Fiske, E. B. (2024). Fiske guide to colleges, 2025 (41st ed.). Sourcebooks.

Webinars You Might Like

Pursue Your Reach Schools with InGenius Prep and Increase Your Admissions Chances

Contact our Enrollment Team to learn more about our services and how we can lead your admissions journey.